Ultimately, after all his years in practice, Dr. Matthew Mulcahy is still most passionate about providing a comfortable and satisfactory dental experience for his patients. He received his undergraduate degree from St. Louis University. Upon earning his Doctorate of Dental Medicine at Washington University, Dr. Mulcahy completed a general practice residency at the Jewish Hospital of St. Louis. Dr. Mulcahy practiced dentistry in Vermont for 15 years before relocating to Nantucket full-time in 2006.
Through his affiliations with the American Dental Association and the Cape Cod Dental Society, Dr. Mulcahy continues his education on a regular basis throughout the year. This keeps him up to date on the latest advance in dental technologies, and stimulated and familiar with the latest advances in dentistry.
Dr. Mulcahy enjoys the Nantucket community and serves as vice-chair of the town finance committee. In his spare time he enjoys gardening, photography, and spending time with his family, including his daughter, Grace, and his three cats.
Almarie graduated from the College of Science and Education with an Associates degree in Tourism and Hospitality Management. She has been Dr. Mulcahys dental assistant since 2007. In addition to assisting during dental procedures and consulting with patients about their treatment plans, Almarie also manages the office. She finds her job very rewarding and enjoys making all our patients feel at home.
Originally from Jamaica, Almarie has lived in Nantucket for over eight years with her family. She has made wonderful friendships here, and feels fortunate to have the experience of living on another beautiful island.
Reviews
Rating 3.8 out of 5 based on 18 reviews
Sort by
newest oldest highest lowestRichard Moran
3 years ago
My 1st major tooth repair with my new Dr was the most comfortable procedure ever. Explained all as he proceeded.
Richard Moran
4 years ago
My 1st major tooth repair with my new Dr was the most comfortable procedure ever. Explained all as he proceeded.
Jeremiah Stratman Electrical Services
4 years ago
My whole family has been going to windmill dental since we moved to Nantucket 3 years ago. Dr. Mulcahey had an excellent bedside manner and is very knowledgeable. He is great with kids. Staff is curteous and professional and appointments have run on time. I would recommend to anyone looking for a dentist on island.
Mariusz R
4 years ago
The worst dentist on the island !!! Terrible customer service !!!! Strongly recommend not to use them !!!! Cancelled my appointment without calling me ahead of time !!! And the dentist mest up my tooth like he didn't know what he was doing. Never use them !!!!
Kayla Rusiecki
4 years ago
My husband had an appointment scheduled that the office cancelled on their own without his knowledge. I personally had an appt one day earlier that I missed. So today, my husband went for his SCHEDULED 8AM APPT- took a day off of work and they cancelled HIS appt because I didn't confirm MY appt! That is unprofessional and this has NEVER happened in ANY other facility I have had appts with. Nobody EVER cancels an unconfirmed appointment (they did not try calling my husband once). My husband needed this appointment due to issues from his last and now he cannot be seen which may cause further tooth damage. Unprofessional and I am NOT impressed- they have lost our business. This shows that this office used their personal feelings because they were unhappy I didn't show for my appointment. Also- they did not even try to call my husbands phone to reach him. They only called my phone to confirm my visit. Consequently they seemed to have found his phone number after we left the office unhappy- hmmm.
Agatha Christian
4 years ago
So surprised at the different experience. I moved to the island recently and changed my dental to Windmill through a recommendation, I moved an appointment for my granddaughter Maddie there for a procedure surprisingly she went home telling her dad she is not afraid of the dentist anymore as its so kid friendly there, Dr Mulcahy, Almarie and staff is so accommodating it felt like home. Thank you all
Michael Schloss
4 years ago
Love the courtesy and professionalism of the staff there me and my partner Jeff both had the complete work up of our mouth and we feel great about it. Thanks Dr Mulcahy, Almarie, Irene and Krissy you guys are amazing.
C_Neg
5 years ago
Professional experience . Dr Mulcathy is one of the best dentists in Nantucket, having nice employees, very honest too and educated, treates his clients well and explain every proces in details. Really enjoyed my dentist appoiments. Both me and my husband did the whole mouth treatment and feel great after. On the top of that I heard he is one of the only ones dentist in ACK who accepts MassHealh, Health Connector. Totally recommend it!
Jeremiah Stratman Electrical Services
5 years ago
My whole family has been going to windmill dental since we moved to Nantucket 3 years ago. Dr. Mulcahey had an excellent bedside manner and is very knowledgeable. He is great with kids. Staff is curteous and professional and appointments have run on time. I would recommend to anyone looking for a dentist on island.
Kayla Rusiecki
5 years ago
My husband had an appointment scheduled that the office cancelled on their own without his knowledge. I personally had an appt one day earlier that I missed. So today, my husband went for his SCHEDULED 8AM APPT- took a day off of work and they cancelled HIS appt because I didn't confirm MY appt! That is unprofessional and this has NEVER happened in ANY other facility I have had appts with. Nobody EVER cancels an unconfirmed appointment (they did not try calling my husband once). My husband needed this appointment due to issues from his last and now he cannot be seen which may cause further tooth damage. Unprofessional and I am NOT impressed- they have lost our business. This shows that this office used their personal feelings because they were unhappy I didn't show for my appointment. Also- they did not even try to call my husbands phone to reach him. They only called my phone to confirm my visit. Consequently they seemed to have found his phone number after we left the office unhappy- hmmm.
Michael Schloss
5 years ago
Love the courtesy and professionalism of the staff there me and my partner Jeff both had the complete work up of our mouth and we feel great about it. Thanks Dr Mulcahy, Almarie, Irene and Krissy you guys are amazing.
Mariusz R
5 years ago
The worst dentist on the island !!! Terrible customer service !!!! Strongly recommend not to use them !!!! Cancelled my appointment without calling me ahead of time !!! And the dentist mest up my tooth like he didn't know what he was doing. Never use them !!!!
Agatha Christian
5 years ago
So surprised at the different experience. I moved to the island recently and changed my dental to Windmill through a recommendation, I moved an appointment for my granddaughter Maddie there for a procedure surprisingly she went home telling her dad she is not afraid of the dentist anymore as its so kid friendly there, Dr Mulcahy, Almarie and staff is so accommodating it felt like home. Thank you all
Barry Rector
5 years ago
My new dentist. Very respectful, very reasonably priced. Has communicated well with me during procedures. Offers professional opinions on best treatment options. Glad I made this choice !!
C_Neg
5 years ago
Professional experience . Dr Mulcathy is one of the best dentists in Nantucket, having nice employees, very honest too and educated, treates his clients well and explain every proces in details. Really enjoyed my dentist appoiments. Both me and my husband did the whole mouth treatment and feel great after. On the top of that I heard he is one of the only ones dentist in ACK who accepts MassHealh, Health Connector. Totally recommend it!
Barry Rector
6 years ago
My new dentist. Very respectful, very reasonably priced. Has communicated well with me during procedures. Offers professional opinions on best treatment options. Glad I made this choice !!
Lisa Doran
7 years ago
DO NOT GO TO THIS DENTIST Dr. Mulcahy is rude and disrespectful..even at my first appointment he doesn't even look directly at u. No "bed side manner" at all..then he removed 2 teeth which was needed. But one was left with "pieces of bone" that cause extreme pain. He wanted to argue with me to the point he said that he would be able to do anything if I kept saying anytjing..he preceeded to try to pull price out without numbing when I explained it was painful he put novicain in and immediately started to pull on the peices. Still only removed one of them and said mother nature needs to take its course even tho I'm still in pain.
Lisa Doran
8 years ago
DO NOT GO TO THIS DENTIST Dr. Mulcahy is rude and disrespectful..even at my first appointment he doesn't even look directly at u. No "bed side manner" at all..then he removed 2 teeth which was needed. But one was left with "pieces of bone" that cause extreme pain. He wanted to argue with me to the point he said that he would be able to do anything if I kept saying anytjing..he preceeded to try to pull price out without numbing when I explained it was painful he put novicain in and immediately started to pull on the peices. Still only removed one of them and said mother nature needs to take its course even tho I'm still in pain.
Rob Hassold
8 years ago
Crown came off right at the start of our vaca. He was willing to come in on a Saturday so I didn't have to deal with the missing crown all weekend. He was professional and accommodating!
Rob Hassold
9 years ago
Crown came off right at the start of our vaca. He was willing to come in on a Saturday so I didn't have to deal with the missing crown all weekend. He was professional and accommodating!
Load more