Dr. Morris, Columbine dentist earned a BS in Education prior to becoming a dentist. This allows her to help patients of all ages feel comfortable and confident in the dental setting. She is passionate about helping her patients understand their dental needs and make informed decisions regarding their care.
Dr. Katie Nagel, dentist in Columbine has been involved in dentistry most of her life. She started in high school working the front desk and later followed in her mothers footsteps to become a hygienist. Dr. Nagel later decided to go to dental school to fulfill a need to serve her patients better. As a hygienist, I loved the personal connection and care I provided my patients, but I just felt like I could and wanted to do more. Returning to school to become a dentist was one of the most rewarding choices in my life. I am thrilled to be able to provide a higher level of care to my patients.
Dr. Nagel graduated 5th in her class from the University of Colorado School of Dental Medicine and was nominated into the Omicron Kappa Upsilon Society which is a prestigious National Dental Honor Society a distinction that reflects her love of education, excellence in clinical care, and moral character. Dr. Nagel lives on a ranch with her husband of 22 years and their two daughters. Their family is heavily involved with basketball and the local 4H program through which her girls show livestock.
She has loved Dentistry since she was a child, and even had a Dental Play-doh Set! She completed her training and started as a Chairside Dental Assistant in January of 2011. In February of 2021, she was asked to take on the role of Office Manager, which is where you will now find her. When she was assisting, she loved being able to help patients get through their treatment smoothly and as comfortably as possible especially our most fearful patients. Our office prides itself on having that family feeling.
When shes not at work, you will usually find her in her garden, with her dog and chickens, or hiking in our beautiful state. During the summertime, she spends many weekends working with her son and husband at Celtic/Scottish Festivals throughout the area.
Andrea comes from a home remodeling construction background of 18 years. She was a project manager and interior designer before the COVID pandemic. She left construction, looking for something that was schedule-friendly for a single mom and still gave her the opportunity for customer service. She enjoys working with her hands and a challenge for her to become better. Dental assisting was a natural fit. Andrea finished the courses to become an assistant during the pandemic and has enjoyed every moment since. She loves working with people and making them feel better. Dentistry has been a real joy for her and she is so happy she made the switch.
Andrea is a Colorado native and in her free time, she enjoys spending time with her seven-year-old son and future hubby. She loves to do just about anything outdoors; hiking, camping, swimming, snowboarding, wakeboarding, etc. She is a fun, outgoing, energetic person who loves making people smile and laugh.
Reviews
Rating 5.0 out of 5 based on 36 reviews
Sort by
newest oldest highest lowestChristina Nazarenus
a year ago
Every is so friendly and efficient!!!
Ronica Kirwin
a year ago
I have been a patient at Plum Creek Dentistry for a few years now, as has my family, and all of us highly recommend them. I am terrified of the dentist and they always put me at ease and ensure I am doing okay throughout the entire process. I have a big fear of metal on my teeth and they do have plastic they can use and it makes a really big difference. They have sedation dentistry options available as well if you need more involved dental care, and it was a breeze getting that done utilizing that option. The entire team is kind, considerate and go out of their way to ensure you are doing okay. Pleasant experience from someone who has a dental fear!
Jimmy Dipiazza
a year ago
The staff at plum Creek Dentistry has been very kind & professional. You can tell they really care about their patients. I would recommend them to anyone. Thank you.
Christine Tolbert
a year ago
Love the new cleaning technician Brenda!! She's wonderful
Justin Marrs
2 years ago
Staff was so nice and comforting. Not only were they thorough, and informative, they were extremely kind making it a pleasant experience. Definitely won't be going anywhere else from now on.
Leanne Guerre
2 years ago
My daughter and I just had our first appointments with Plum Creek Dentistry and they were amazing. The staff was so friendly and they made us feel so comfortable. I will definitely be back and would 100 percent recommend them to others.
Eve Boyer Full Circle Beauty
2 years ago
So happy we found this place for all of our family dental needs! Super friendly staff!
Judy Enneking
2 years ago
Last week, while visiting Littleton Colorado, one of my crowns suddenly fell out! Not being familiar with Littleton I took a chance and called Plum Creek Dentistry. Melissa answered the phone and was so friendly and made me feel so welcomed. She made an appointment for me that same day. I was so relieved and a bit nervous. When I got there I met Dr. Nagel. She explained my options so clearly put my crown back on and I was on my way. Thank you everyone for all your help.
Bruce B.
2 years ago
The dentist that worked on me on my recent appointment was Doctor Morris. She reminded me of how Dr. Glass used to treat his patients. She was very professional and explained everything she was doing and what needed to be done. I felt very comfortable with her.
Brian Barnum
2 years ago
Fantastic new patient experience. The staff are friendly, knowledgeable, and comforting. I have a lot of dental fear, and my nerves are calm after my visit.
Karen Embree
2 years ago
Dr Nagel can do it all- clean teeth, fill a cavity, and create cosmetic magic! Highly recommend!
Kevin Mossey
2 years ago
Really friendly staff, Dr. Nagel was also friendly and thorough in her cleaning/inspection of my teeth. Initially turned down their offer of sample floss because I don't like to use the stuff with teflon that's very popular now and to my pleasant surprise they had more environmentally friendly samples! Oh, and they had a really awesome unexpected new patient perk - I was able to select from a variety of options and ultimately went with the bamboo electric toothbrush, with bamboo and charcoal fiber heads, keeping in line with the environmental concern!
Dorothy Burdick
2 years ago
Arvetta Rose did an excellent job cleaning my teeth. She is a very nice person
Leroy Nielsen
2 years ago
Excellent dental care!
Jeannie G
2 years ago
I broke a front tooth, of course on a weekend. Melissa was able to get me in Monday morning! All the staff were very understanding and sensitive to my past dental trauma and current insecurity. Thank you all for getting me fixed up and back to my normal life.
Nathan Cameron
2 years ago
Fast, courteous, and professional are the three words that come to mind from my visit this morning. The explained everything very well! Thank you for your great service! Would recommend!
Cindy Janechild
2 years ago
Friendly, professional, complete care and helpful. I was very happy with all levels of care. Thanks
Nathan Newell
2 years ago
Today was my first visit with Dr Nagel. As someone who has had bad experiences with dentists over the years, she made me feel very comfortable. She has a very gentle touch and chair side manner. The office has a very warm and inviting atmosphere and the staff is very friendly and helpful. Definitely glad I chose Plum Creek!
Ronald Lutz
2 years ago
Addressed dental problem with minimal discomfort with no after visit discomfort
Jim Berry
2 years ago
So advanced in technology, never feel the numbing shot, no stuff going down your throat. Easy Peasy! Great experience for a dentist....right?!?
Load more